It's quite extraordinary to take one of the greatest sf characters of all time and turn him into a miserable git, like Levin from Anna Karenina but without the love interest. -- Nicholas Whyte, Infinity Plus
I must assume that there are those who like this kind of writing but as far as I can see, this kind of fan fiction is barely worth printing, let alone publishing in the beautiful package it has been given. -- Duncan Lawie, Zone-SF
...a genuinely thoughtful entertainment on a number of levels. -- Andy Sawyer, The Alien Online