Although the Book is appropriately suspenseful and a delight to read--even the minor characters are distinctive and vividly seen--its most powerful moments are those that describe real horrors. -- Regina Marler, Amazon.com
From an ivy league Author with an advanced degree, the Book is learned, well-written, but oddly conventional and un-ambitious. It ends up being very normal. -- Inchoatus
Like all reworkings, it is more knowing, and less fun, than its original. -- Jane Stevenson, The Guardian
It's an enjoyable journey for those who dare to take it. -- W. R. Greer, Reviews Of Books
Once you pick this novel up it won't take you long to get to the end. -- Michael D. Clark, The Houston Chronicle
There is much to enjoy, and it is better than a lot of the rather similar Books doing the rounds at the moment. -- SFFWorld
The Historian is an admirable work, one that will certainly resonate in some ways, but to be fair it must also be said that the novel's studied history and excessive traveloguing suck from it much of the life it might have had. -- Tony Buchsbaum, January Magazine
At 642 pages, the beautifully written and creepily realistic novel feels too long at the beginning, but then way too short as the reader eagerly yet reluctantly approaches the final climax. -- Terry Miller Shannon, BoorReporter.com