Clarke proves the mighty potential of the fantasy genre by taking it in a startling new direction. -- Inchoatus.com
Add in an increasingly evil menace from the fairies, ceaseless English rain, and Clarke's fondness for winter and Buffy the Vampire Slayer, and you begin to appreciate the novel's moody vibe... -- John Burns, Striaght.com
This is the strangest...and, as we gratefully come to understand, the "norrellest"...magic a Book lover could wish for. -- Michael Alec Rose, BookPage
It could be backhanded praise that Clarke's characters are so eccentrically human that you want to know where each and every one of them winds up, but maybe she's saving it for the sequel. -- Grady Hendrix, The Village Voice
Clarke mingles military and magical history with remarkable success, conveying the horrors of war along with her own surreal inventions, such as a fleet of decoy ships made of rain or a battlefield where hands of mud pull French cavalry to the ground. -- Ron Charles, The Christian Science Monitor
It is a Book for a favourite armchair, for readers in patched cardigans, with log fires and buttered muffins. Should your present circumstances offer none of these comforts, do not be deterred. You need only dip into this big, bubbling cauldron of a Book to feel that Clarke has conjured them all for you. -- Helen Brown, The Telegraph
is in fact an elegant and witty historical fantasy which deserves to be judged on its own (considerable) merit. -- Matthew Alexander, The Telegraph
...a novel destined to become a classic. -- Jana Kraus, MostlyFiction.com
The most worrying weakness, though, is the Book's low emotional temperature. -- Michel Faber, The Guardian
For all its ingenuity and charm, this Book is as insubstantial as fairy gold. -- Jane Stevenson, The Guardian
Susanna Clarke has clearly done everything in her power to convey her singular fictional vision. -- Michael Berry, The San Francisco Chronicle
This isn't a stellar fantasy novel, it's a stellar novel. -- Celia McGee, new York Daily News
I read the last 250 pages at a gallop, holding my breath most of the time. -- Colette Bancroft, The St. Petersburg Times
...Clarke's most impressive show of Authorial skill is in how she resolves this tension without destroying it. -- Nisi Shawl, The Seattle Times
Clarke's novel, I'm pleased to say, just about deserves the fuss. -- Gregory Maguire, The New York Times
At its best and most uncluttered, this Book delivers splendid and unpredictable surprises. -- Janet Maslin, The New York Times
It may be just as well that Susanna Clarke's first novel, "Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell," is nearly as big as a house, since this is the kind of Book you want to move into and settle down in for a long stay. -- Laura Miller, Salon.com
...a fine mix of 19th-century novelistic charm and the 21st-century desire for breathless storytelling. -- Dorman T. Shindler, St. Louis Post Dispatch
She's a great admirer of Charles Dickens and has produced a work every bit as enjoyable as The Pickwick Papers, with more than a touch of the early Anne Rice thrown in for good measure. -- Ed Halloran, The Denver Post
What stands out here is the sheer elegance of the writing, the style of which has been likened to what Authors such as Jane Austen and Dickens might have produced had they been genre writers. -- John Berlyne, SFRevu