Readers looking for "something different" will be well rewarded by spending some time in Wright's most unusual school. -- Drew Bittner, SFRevu
It does not work as a stand alone Book, and might not be enough to encourage all readers to pick up the next installment. -- Renee A. Mallett, Fantastica Daily
This is truly excellent, although I need to mention that it's the first half, or possibly the first third, of the novel, not the whole thing. -- Elisabeth Carey, New England Science Fiction Association, Inc.
is is a work that will be judged ultimately by its sequel, a sequel that has been given no small task in fulfilling what is in my mind Wright's most promising work yet, and my single favorite work by the Author. -- Jay, FantasyBookSpot.com
Perhaps if Laura Antoniou were to get a degree in physics and both Roger Zelazny and Neil Gaiman were dating her and they were all reading Hesiod in the original Greek and studying Christian theology -- they might write something like John C. Wright's novel. -- Paula Guran, Dark Echo