But the world of man is a complex and capricious place. Maggot must master its strange ways if he is to survive... let alone win the heart and hand of the Lady Portia.
Finlay's society of trolls are unlike any you've ever read before, and his matriarchal medieval world, pitted as they are against an analog of Native American tribesmen, provides a rich setting for many poignant social and political insights.
Finlay has plainly made a spectacular jump into a new stage of his career, which will hopefully be a long and productive one. -- Paul Di Filippo, Scifi.com
The Prodigal Troll starts off strong but fails to carry the momentum throughout the Book. -- Jeff Wheeler, Deep Magic Book Reviews
I wanted much more and hopefully the sequel will provide. -- Henry Leon Lazarus, philly1.com
I think this novel is a promising start, but that Finlay has to work a bit on the novel writing art. -- Cheryl Morgan, Emerald City