...readers looking for a sequel that matches the original will be disappointed. -- Sam Lubell, SFRevu
Descriptions are sparse, the text is always pushing the action forward -- Mark McSherry, Icshi
... this volume honors its predecessor in a fairly commendable manner...but it's not, and possibly never could be, the Slan II from some imaginary 1943 that we all dream of. -- Paul Di Filippo, Scifi.com
...reads as if the grandmaster wrote the tale... -- http://harrietklausner.wwwi.com/review/slan_hunter_anderson