As the complex story unfolds, Rochefort's dreams of the future grow increasingly stranger and more contradictory. He realises he must act but, how? What is the right choice? And how much of the future will depend on what he does?
A highlight of the year? I think so. -- Iain Emsley, SFRevu
...this is a very fine novel with excellent characterisation, complex plotting and a suburb grasp, not only of history but also of human motivation. -- Pauline Morgan
The characters are memorable, the romantic plot heart-breaking, the writing gritty and crisp, the plot is clever and well-executed, with good pacing, and if they ever do make that Jolie/Crowe film version, there are enough set-pieces to let them sweep the board at the Oscars. -- David Kennedy, dkennedy.org
...we do not quite forgive 1610, because so much of it is hoohaw, so much of it could have been skipped if Gentle had only trusted her readers to get the point a little earlier. -- John Clute, Scifi.com
This is my favorite Book of the year so far, period. And with only one month to go I shall be very surprised (if utterly delighted) to find anything to touch it. -- Cheryl Morgan, Emerald City
An Arthur C Clarke-award nominee in waiting. -- Jon Courtenay Grimwood, The Guardian