But the cathedral isn't the empty edifice it appears to be. Its history is very much alive in the present day-and it's calling out to Ned.
This is a troubling Book for Kay, whose narrative voice is so strong for fantasies involving poetic, heroic language... bringing that narrative to contemporary fantasy somehow trivializes the content. -- Inchoatus
While sophisticated readers will like much of the novel, ultimately they may end less satisfied. -- Mel Jacob, SFRevu
...while his willingness to come at the genre from a different angle with Ysabel hasn't resulted in a bad novel, he's not fully on form here either. -- Thomas M. Wagner, SFReviews.NET
The writing is pure Kay, and I'd read it for that alone, but the story is oddly disappointing... -- Alma A. Hromic, SFsite.com
Part fantasy, part history and all literary, Ysabel could only be written by a veteran novelist. -- Candice G. Ball, Calgary Herald
As Guy Gavriel Kay's first venture into contemporary fantasy, Ysabel is just fantastic. -- Douglas Barbour, Edmonton Journal